Winter Garden
It’s not a matter of if.
It’s a matter of when.
That’s basically how the review of Without Precedent, a book by 9-11 Commission co-chairs Thomas H. Keane and Lee H. Hamilton, ends in last Sunday’s New YorkTimes Book Review.
I think it’s a safe bet.
On Feb, 26, 1993, I took the ferry from Hoboken to the World Financial Center on the way to work. It was an extravagant thing to do, given that I was working on 57th Street at the time. Taking the ferry meant having to take a 20-minute subway ride from the financial district, as opposed to a 5-minute ride from 34th S
treet if I crossed the river on the Path train. There was also a Path train to the World Trade Center, but I never rode that. If I was going to end up that far downtown, I was going to cross on the open ferry.
I enjoyed taking the long way to work. A boat ride beats riding a subway under a river, and cruising up to the foot of the towers—the World Financial Center and the World Trade Center—made for spectacular sightseeing. I loved the net effect of old skyscrapers, such as the Woolworth Building, clustering with the newer glass towers at the base of the soaring WTC. On clear days, it was like a monumental glass and concrete forest. On foggy days, it was a mountain and a monolith. It was different every day.
There’s not much to look at from the windows of a Path train under the river.
My walk from the ferry landing to the uptown subway started at the World Financial Center marina—the most expensive place to park a boat anywhere, I believe. One of the more preposterous yachts had a small blue helicopter perched on its roof. Donald Trump had a boat in that water. From there, I entered the Winter Garden in front of the World Financial Center, a large glass-fronted structure with palm trees in it. It had a pricy mall on its mezzani
ne, and there was often a stage set up for some event or another against the glass frontage. The backdrop of the stage, therefore, included the marina, the Hudson, and New Jersey. I exited the Winter Garden on the far side after climbing the large marble staircase that spanned three sides of the polygon floorplan.
The Winter Garden was bright and wide open. A guy I worked with said climbing the stairs gave him terrible vertigo. He never went in the place.
Next, I crossed an enclosed elevated walkway called the North Bridge. It crossed over the West Side Highway to Tower One of the WTC. I would pass through the lobby of Tower One and go downstairs to a less glitzy mall than the one at the World Financial Center. At the far end of the midway was the subway—the N or R train took me to 57th Street.
That February morning, I noticed that Don Imus was broadcasting live from the Winter Garden stage. Not worth stopping, I thought. I was already pushing it for time. And it was Don Imus.
I usually stopped at night. Sometimes there would be something great, like an orchestra playing a new score to W.F. Murnau’s horror classic Nosferatu with the 1922 silent film showing on a large screen above the stage. Sometimes
it was sheer spectacle. Once I saw Robert Fripp recording overlapping tape loops of sythesized guitar noise, playing the random pile up of sound to a rather large audience. This didn’t belong on a stage. It belonged in his basement. I was riveted.
No, Imus didn’t hold me up at all.
When I got back from lunch that afternoon (another bit of extravagance—I hit an art dealers’ convention at the Park Avenue Armory) , I heard about the explosion at the World Trade Center. Everyone looked out the southwest corner window of our 26th floor office. We couldn’t see much. The first reports on the radio said that a transformer exploded at the Path station, which was completely believable. I think a rattled Don Imus, right there on the scene, was the first with that speculation. I imagine him, mic in hand, looking around under the table for his cowboy hat. But, listening to the radio later, we learned that this was a little bigger than an electrical fire on the tracks.
It was a bomb. A truck bomb, as it turned out, set off several floors down in the parking garage under the towers. This suggested serious penetration—a lot of driving around underground before detonation. Six people died and thousands we
re injured. The evacuation of workers from the smoke-filled towers made for big drama throughout the day. It was noted that the narrow stairway evacuation route was somewhat inadequate for such tall buildings. It was snowing. On TV we saw people leaving the building, some with their faces, especially their noses and mouths, blackened by smoke. They had snowflakes in their hair and on their shoulders and terror in their irritated eyes.
At nearly 8:00 pm in Hoboken—I took the 34th Street Path train back, of course—a few people were still milling around with blackened mouths and noses. At that hour they looked like tired, late train commuters who happened to have had a Warner Brothers cartoon bomb go off in their faces earlier in the day. It was beyond strange.
The WTC opened again several months later. The entire perimeter of the building was lined with huge planters to keep all vehicles a safe distance away. The lobby would from then on be crowded with people passing through new security turnstiles to get on the high speed elevators. I’d see this pretty much every morning after 2000 when my company moved our offices to William Street, three blocks from the WTC Plaza. The ferry would become my most direct route to work.
Sometimes in the North Bridge there would be a crafts fair. There was a big one at Christmastime—I did almost all my Christmas shopping there one year. I bought Maureen’s favorite hat there. And once a year there would be a display of photographs that won Associated Press photojournalism awards. Most of the photos had to do with war, poverty, or terrorism, usually in the Middle East, Africa, Latin America or London.
A lot of people who worked in the towers said they figured lightning wouldn’t strike twice. I was of the other school. It was usually in the North Bridge, especially during the AP awards show, that I consciously thought they’d strike again at this obvious target.











